Why recognition matters, but the everyday experience of being noticed, appreciated and trusted can matter even more.
Key Takeaways | TL;DR
- Recognition programmes can be valuable, but having one doesn’t automatically mean people feel valued.
- Feeling valued is shaped through everyday interactions, not only formal moments of recognition.
- Different people may experience value differently. What matters to one person may mean very little to another.
- Sometimes valuing someone means noticing what they’re good at and creating more opportunity for them to use it.
- Before adding another recognition initiative, understand how valued people actually feel and what is shaping that experience.
Every now and then, Calum will say something to me that catches me slightly off guard.
We’ve been best friends since Year 8 and business partners for nearly a decade, so we’re probably well beyond the stage of regularly telling each other how brilliant we are.
But occasionally he’ll tell me that I’m really good at something.
Sometimes it’s a passing comment. Other times it’s reflected in a decision. He’ll suggest that I take ownership of something because he thinks it plays to my strengths, or we’ll move responsibilities around because there are areas where one of us is clearly better than the other.
They’re small moments, but they matter to me.
Not because I need Calum to formally recognise my performance.
Because they tell me something much more human:
He sees what I bring.
And I think there’s an important difference between being recognised and feeling valued.
Recognition is an action. Value is an experience.
Organisations have become much better at creating ways to recognise people.
There are employee awards, peer-to-peer recognition platforms, values nominations, thank-you schemes, service awards, bonuses and increasingly sophisticated technology designed to make appreciation easier and more visible.
I don’t think any of those things are inherently bad. Done well, they can create moments that genuinely mean something to people.
But having a recognition programme doesn’t necessarily mean your people feel valued.
An employee could receive an award on Friday and have their contribution repeatedly ignored in meetings on Monday. Someone might collect points through a recognition platform while feeling that nobody understands what they’re actually good at. Another person may receive plenty of praise but never be trusted with an opportunity to grow.
The organisation can be recognising them while their everyday experience is telling them something completely different.
Feeling valued often happens in much smaller moments
When I think about the managers I’ve valued most throughout my own career, I don’t immediately remember formal recognition.
I remember Stuart, one of my managers at Experian.
He was empathetic. He coached me. He cared about what was happening in my life outside work and took time to help me develop. More importantly, I felt as though he genuinely understood me as a person rather than simply somebody performing a role.
I don’t remember whether Stuart ever nominated me for an award.
I remember how he made me feel.
That’s the bit I think organisations can accidentally miss when recognition becomes a programme to manage.
Feeling valued might come from somebody asking for your opinion because they genuinely respect it. It might be your manager remembering something important happening in your life. It could be being trusted with a difficult piece of work, receiving thoughtful feedback or simply hearing someone say, “You’re really good at this.”
None of those moments require a recognition platform.
But they require somebody to notice.
Value isn’t the same for everybody
There’s another reason I think this matters.
People aren’t identical.
Public praise might make one employee feel fantastic and another deeply uncomfortable. One person might value a promotion, while somebody else values flexibility because it allows them to collect their children from school. Someone might want greater responsibility; another might simply want their manager to acknowledge how much they’re already carrying.
That’s difficult to standardise.
And perhaps we shouldn’t try to.
The role of a recognition programme can be to create opportunities for appreciation. The danger comes when the existence of the programme becomes evidence that people must therefore feel valued.
The only way to understand that is to ask them.
Four questions to ask about whether people genuinely feel valued
- Do people feel that what they bring is noticed?
Not simply whether good performance is rewarded, but whether people’s individual strengths, ideas and contribution are actually seen. - What happens between the recognition moments?
Look at everyday meetings, feedback, decisions and interactions. They will usually have far more influence on someone’s experience than an occasional award. - Does appreciation look the same for everybody?
Understand what feeling valued means to different people rather than assuming everybody wants recognition in the same form. - Does recognition translate into trust and opportunity?
Sometimes the strongest signal that someone’s contribution matters is being listened to, trusted or given the opportunity to do more of what they’re good at.
Where belonging can help us look deeper
Value is one of the three conditions in our Lens of Belonging, alongside Authenticity and Connection.
For us, it means:
“What I bring is seen and valued here.”
That distinction matters. It’s not simply I receive recognition here. It’s whether my contribution, perspective, strengths and presence feel as though they have genuine standing in this organisation.
Recognition can absolutely help create that experience.
But it isn’t the experience itself.
Final thought
I don’t think organisations should abandon recognition programmes.
I think they should be careful not to confuse having one with creating a workplace where people genuinely feel valued.
The moments I remember haven’t generally involved awards, platforms or company-wide announcements. They’ve involved people who noticed something in me, trusted me, challenged me, encouraged me or created room for me to contribute.
Calum probably won’t remember half the comments he’s made to me over the years.
I do.
And perhaps that’s the point.
Some of the most meaningful experiences we create for people at work won’t appear in a programme, strategy or dashboard. They’ll happen in an ordinary conversation between two human beings where one person leaves knowing something they didn’t quite know before:
What I bring matters here.
Go Beyond Recognition. Understand Whether People Feel Valued
Understand the experience behind the programme
At Thrive at Work, our Discover work combines organisational evidence, in-person listening and our Lens of Belonging to understand whether people experience Authenticity, Connection and Value, and what in their everyday working lives may be strengthening or weakening those conditions.
Because recognition is something you can implement.
Feeling valued is something you have to understand.


